The Baofeng UV-25 is the clear winner here. This comparison isn't particularly close given the significant gap in overall performance scores and the UV-25's superior feature set at a lower price point.
The single most important differentiator is the overall score spread: 76 versus 34 points. This massive difference suggests the UV-25 offers substantially better performance, build quality, or user experience. The UV-25 also includes GPS functionality, which the HA1G lacks entirely, and costs $25 less while delivering confirmed 10W transmission power.
The UV-25 is ideal for budget-conscious hams who want a capable handheld with GPS navigation and solid core performance. The HA1G might appeal only to someone with very specific hardware requirements or compatibility needs that aren't captured in this comparison, though that's difficult to justify given the score disparity.
We recommend the Baofeng UV-25. It delivers better value, more features, and demonstrably stronger overall performance. Unless you have a particular reason to avoid Baofeng products or need something the HA1G specifically offers, the choice is straightforward. The UV-25 represents better bang for your dollar across nearly every measurable dimension.
By use case
Intermediate hams needing advanced features
Its superior channel count and GPS features support advanced field operations.
Budget-conscious beginner needing basic coverage
The HA1G offers essential waterproof protection at a lower initial cost.
Operators needing reliable waterproof field use
The IP67 rating ensures reliable communication during wet or muddy trips.
Experienced hams needing multi-band flexibility
The UV-25's design is better suited for operators requiring diverse frequency coverage.
Emergency preparedness and preppers
Its robust IP67 rating makes it ideal for unpredictable, harsh environments.
Made your choice?
Baofeng UV-25PICK
$51.99 on AmazonRetevis HA1G
$71.99 on Amazon