Y23UV-98PLUS vs Yaesu FT-60R

The Y23UV-98PLUS is the clear winner here. This isn't particularly close given the significant price and capability gap between these two radios.

The single most important differentiator is feature set versus cost. Radio A delivers APRS and GPS functionality for $85, doubling Radio B's transmission power at half the price. Radio B's $190 price tag buys you essentially a basic dual-band transceiver with no modern features and weak 5-watt output. The overall scores reflect this disparity accurately, with Radio A scoring 72 to Radio B's 39.

The Y23UV-98PLUS is ideal for budget-conscious operators who want modern conveniences like APRS tracking and GPS capability without breaking the bank. The Yaesu FT-60R might appeal only to operators seeking a heritage brand or specific compatibility with existing systems, though at this price point there are better options available.

Buy the Y23UV-98PLUS unless you have a specific technical requirement only the FT-60R meets. For most amateur radio use cases, particularly portable and emergency applications, Radio A provides dramatically better value and more useful features. The choice to recommend Radio B would be difficult to justify.