Retevis A3 vs Retevis RA89

The Retevis RA89 is the clear winner here. Despite costing $26 less, it significantly outperforms the A3 with a much higher overall score of 58 versus 31. The most important differentiator is CHIRP compatibility on the RA89, which allows users to program the radio via computer rather than navigating the radio's interface manually. This is a substantial quality-of-life advantage that justifies the score difference.

The A3 has no compelling advantages. It costs more while scoring lower and lacks the programmability features that modern amateur radio enthusiasts expect. Unless you specifically need something the A3 uniquely offers that wasn't captured in this comparison, there's no reason to choose it.

The RA89 is ideal for someone seeking an affordable handheld that won't frustrate you during programming. The A3 might appeal only to someone with very specific legacy requirements or specific band needs not reflected here.

For most amateur radio operators evaluating these two radios, the RA89 is the recommended purchase. You'll save money, get better overall value, and enjoy a more user-friendly programming experience.