Icom IC-2300H vs TYT TH-9800

The TYT TH-9800 is the clear winner here. While the Icom IC-2300H offers higher transmit power at 65W compared to the TYT's 50W, this advantage is overwhelmed by the TYT's significantly better overall score of 53 versus 43. Both radios lack modern features like DMR, APRS, and GPS, and both support CHIRP programming, so neither has a feature advantage.

The single most important differentiator is value. The TYT TH-9800 costs just $220 with a known, reasonable price point, while the Icom's price remains unknown, making comparison difficult. The TYT's proven affordability combined with its higher overall score suggests better real-world performance and user satisfaction.

The Icom IC-2300H appeals only to users who specifically need the extra 15W of power and can't find its price prohibitive. The TYT TH-9800 suits budget-conscious operators seeking a well-reviewed, affordable mobile radio with adequate power for most applications.

Get the TYT TH-9800. Its 10-point advantage in overall score, transparent pricing, and solid power output make it the smarter purchase for amateur radio operators prioritizing reliability and value.