Baofeng DM-1701 vs Y23UV-98PLUS

The Y23UV-98PLUS edges out as the better overall value with a higher score of 72 versus 63, despite costing just $15 more. However, the winner ultimately depends on your intended use case.

The single most important differentiator is feature set versus simplicity. The Baofeng DM-1701 specializes in DMR digital mode, making it ideal for coordinated group communications on DMR networks. The Y23UV-98PLUS takes a broader approach with APRS and GPS capabilities, enabling location tracking and emergency positioning features that appeal to more diverse amateur radio applications.

The DM-1701 suits operators who specifically need DMR repeater access and are willing to accept a narrower feature scope for that focus. The Y23UV-98PLUS makes sense for general-purpose operators who value location services and want flexibility across different modes of operation.

We recommend the Y23UV-98PLUS for most users. Its higher overall score, GPS and APRS functionality, and $15 premium represent solid value for the expanded capabilities. Only choose the DM-1701 if DMR is your primary operating mode and budget is the decisive factor.