RadioRanked verdict
Updated Nov 2026Comet SBB-1NMO Compact Dual-Band Mobile vs Midland MXTA25 Ghost Antenna
Our pick
Comet SBB-1NMO Compact Dual-Band Mobile$58.99
The Comet SBB-1 is the clear winner for dual-band mobile work. The most important differentiator is electrical length: the Comet operates at 0.59 wavelengths on UHF, delivering realistic 4.7 dBi gain, while the Midland is severely compromised at just 0.14 wavelengths, yielding negative gain. The Comet's VHF performance is electrically short but functional at 0.7 dBi; the Midland is GMRS-only and not viable for amateur dual-band use.
The Midland does report higher owner satisfaction (4.8 versus 4.4 stars), but with 1199 reviews versus 45, that reflects a much larger user base rather than evidence of superiority. Both cost roughly 60 dollars. The Comet's lower score reflects its smaller review sample, not inferior specifications.
Buy the Comet SBB-1 if you need dual-band mobile performance on VHF and UHF. The Midland MXTA25 suits only GMRS users who prioritize compactness over antenna efficiency.
We recommend the Comet for amateur radio operators seeking practical dual-band mobile coverage.
By use case
Which should you buy?
Truck or SUV owner with a high roof
Its 5/8 wave UHF section and roof-mounted ground plane give real gain on high vehicle roofs.
SBB-1NMOLow-clearance garage or car wash parker
Its short rigid body clears low garages and car washes, trading range for a near-invisible profile.
MXTA25Buyer choosing the less expensive option
It costs less than the alternative while still delivering usable VHF and UHF performance on a vehicle.
SBB-1NMOOperator using GMRS only
Midland's listed GMRS band matches a GMRS-only operator's needs more directly than Comet's VHF coverage does.
MXTA25Operator focused on 70cm
Comet's 5/8 wave UHF element gives it the stronger 70cm performance of the two.
SBB-1NMO
Reasons to choose Comet SBB-1NMO Compact Dual-Band Mobile
- 2% cheaper ($58.99 vs $59.99)
- Also covers VHF (146 MHz)
- Flexible, so it survives being bent
Reasons to choose Midland MXTA25 Ghost Antenna
- Also covers GMRS (465 MHz)
- Lower profile by 12.5 in (89 mm vs 406 mm)
Spec battle
Spec-by-spec breakdown
Made your choice?
Comet SBB-1NMO Compact Dual-Band MobilePICK
$58.99 on AmazonMidland MXTA25 Ghost Antenna
$59.99 on AmazonMore head-to-heads