The Baofeng DM-32UV GPS APRS is the clear winner here. This comparison isn't even close given the massive gap in overall scores and feature set.
The single most important differentiator is the feature richness versus bare basics. The Baofeng includes DMR digital mode, APRS positioning, and GPS capabilities, making it a modern multimode radio. The Retevis A3 appears to be a basic analog-only radio with virtually no advanced features. This explains why the Baofeng scores 83 versus the A3's concerning 31.
The Baofeng should appeal to anyone wanting modern digital capabilities and emergency positioning features at an exceptional price point. The Retevis A3 might only interest someone with extremely basic needs and tight budgets, though even then the feature gap makes it hard to recommend.
Buy the Baofeng DM-32UV GPS APRS without hesitation. It delivers substantially more capability for just twenty dollars more, and the scoring difference reflects real-world performance gaps. The Retevis A3 doesn't present a compelling argument for purchase under any reasonable scenario given its poor rating and feature limitations.
By use case
Beginner wanting digital modes and GPS
Its DMR, APRS, and GPS features make it a superior entry point for digital operations.
Strictly monitoring analog repeaters
The A3's dedicated analog VHF/UHF focus is perfect for basic repeater monitoring.
Operator needing high feature count value
The Baofeng offers significantly more features, including APRS and GPS, for the price.
Budget-conscious new licensee needing basic coverage
The A3 provides basic multi-band analog coverage without the complexity of digital modes.
Portable field use needing digital connectivity
The combination of GPS and DMR makes it ideal for structured field and public service use.
Made your choice?
Baofeng DM-32UV GPS APRSPICK
$59.99 on AmazonRetevis A3
$99.99 on Amazon